This round we're going to consider one critique of fully open adoptions. Have you ever heard--or perhaps even made--statements like these?
"We have medical histories and can share the information we have about their birth parents with our children now. If they feel a need to initiate contact with their birth families when they are adults, we will fully support them."
"The decision to have a relationship with her bio family should be hers when she is ready. Creating a relationship between them before she wants it might cause issues in the future."
"Children deserve to have just one family during childhood and not to deal with anything adoption-related until they are more mature. A fully open adoption robs a child of a normal childhood."
These statements are from people participating in closed and semi-open adoptions. I paraphrased them slightly, but left the meanings intact.
The writers share a certain point-of-view: that direct contact during early childhood between birth families and children placed for adoption may not be the best idea. Adopted persons should be free to initiate relationships with their first families--or not--on their own timetable. The parents (first and adoptive) in an adoption shouldn't make such an important and personal decision for them.
What is your response? Do you agree or disagree? Why?
A lot of my beliefs regarding adoption and openness in adoption were formed long before I ever thought I would be an adoptive mom, long before I ever experienced infertility.
As a teen, I dated (and almost married!) a guy who was an adoptee. He knew a bit about his bio parents but never saw a reason to find them or learn more. That was a bizarre notion to me - I just couldn't imagine not knowing anything about them or what similarities there may be.
As an adult, I found myself dating a man (now DH) who has a half sister that had been placed for adoption. A sister he knew nothing about for a good portion of his life. By the time I came on the scene, reunion had long since happened and a relationship had begun to form. I was enthralled with this relationship and I watched with interest at the different dynamics between my now MIL, my SIL, DH and all the other people now involved in the adoption "triad".
And then I found myself walking down the road towards becoming an adoptive mom... full of questions. Questions for the adoptee. Questions for the b-mom. Questions for the a-mom. And questions for myself and where my heart & head truly was.
Openness for me isn't just about having medical history or knowing how to contact MG's birthfamily when she wants to. It's about forming a life long relationship between a myriad of people who all have one thing in common - love for a little girl. Why would I deprive her, or any of us for that matter, of that love?
Bonds are formed over time. It will take time for MG's birth family and myself to form a relationship that all parties are comfortable with. We need that time now, while MG is still too young to recognize the awkwardness of it. Sure, when MG is older she'll be able to make her own decisions regarding contact but until then, I am the keeper of that relationship and it's up to me to ensure I give it every opportunity to grow and flourish. In time, it will become a part of her life and she will have to reconcile it with who she is.
But for now, we explain the aspects of adoption. We tell her about HER story and most importantly, we let her know that she is lucky to have so many people that care about her and love her. And when a gift shows up on our doorstep, like it did last week, I get to tell my daughter it's from her OH family. I don't feel fear. I don't feel panic. I just feel the joy emanating from my daughter as she tears open the package and smiles into the camera, saying "thank you Grandma J".